Blog December 2, 2020
Heightened Scrutiny of Specimens of Use at U.S. Trademark Office
- Person title
Unlike in most countries, in the United States trademark registrations are supposed to reflect marks actually in use in commerce. Trademark rights in the U.S. are earned through use, not simply purchased. Nonetheless, there has been a growing problem at the U.S. Trademark Office regarding the submission of specimens of use that in fact do not represent actual use of the mark in U.S. commerce. On the heels of announcing a new rule requiring all foreign-domiciled applicants to be represented by a U.S. licensed attorney to try to combat this issue, in July 2019 the U.S. Trademark Office released a new guide instructing its examining attorneys to carefully review specimens of use that appear to be digitally created/altered or mere mockups.
Examining attorneys may conduct their own research to substantiate the authenticity of specimens. Applicants who submit screen shots of websites may be able to help avoid being questioned by including in the specimen the URL for where the original may be located on the Internet. If a specimen appears to be digitally created/altered or merely a mockup, the examining attorney must issue a refusal on the grounds that the specimen does not show actual use of the mark in U.S. commerce. The examining attorney must also issue a request for detailed information about the specimen to help determine whether the mark is actually in use in U.S. commerce. Evidently, examining attorneys themselves will not raise the issue of fraud, though that is ultimately the underlying concern and could be raised by a third party in filing an opposition to an application or a petition to cancel an issued registration.
Requiring additional information about suspicious specimens of use is an important step in maintaining the integrity of the federal trademark register. Trademark applicants and their U.S. attorneys should be sensitive to the heightened scrutiny devoted to the review of specimens and avoid whenever possible the submission of specimens that even "hint" they may not be authentic.
Author: Keith A. Barritt
The opinions expressed are those of the authors on the date noted above and do not necessarily reflect the views of Fish & Richardson P.C., any other of its lawyers, its clients, or any of its or their respective affiliates. This post is for general information purposes only and is not intended to be and should not be taken as legal advice. No attorney-client relationship is formed.
Blog December 9, 2019
Blog July 3, 2019
New Rule Requires Foreign-Domiciled Trademark Applicants, Registrants, and Parties at TTAB to Be Represented by U.S. Attorney
Blog April 2, 2018
USPTO Pilot Program Regarding Specimen Authenticity
Blog July 5, 2017
U.S. Trademark Office Clarifies Filing Deadlines for Resurrecting Dead Applications and Registrations
Blog June 8, 2017
Even GOOGLE Can Google After All
Blog May 19, 2017
What Does The "In" in "Incontestable" Mean?
Blog February 7, 2017
U.S. Trademark Office Sharpens Machete for Pruning Deadwood
Blog February 3, 2017
FDA Final Guidance on Nonproprietary Names of Biological Products
Blog August 1, 2016
Final FDA Guidance on "Low Risk Wellness" Products Adopts Novel Approach for Exempting Devices From Regulation
Blog December 12, 2022
USPTO Updates Deadline to Respond to Trademark Office Actions
Article August 22, 2022
Principal Vivian Cheng Featured in Law.com Q&A Series "How I Made Partner"
Article June 16, 2022
Principal Cynthia Walden and Associate Sarah Kelleher Author World Intellectual Property Review Article "Selling the Intangible in Fashion: What Does It...
Blog October 5, 2021
ITC Monthly Wrap-Up: September 2021
Article July 23, 2021
Fish Principal Cindy Walden Authors World IP Review Article "Brand Owner's Friend: the Lanham Act at 75"
Blog January 19, 2021
Trademark, Copyright Legislation Passed as Part of COVID-19 Relief Bill
Blog December 9, 2020
New York Passes Post-Mortem Right of Publicity Law
Blog June 2, 2020
USPTO Announces Further Relief for Certain Trademark-Related Fees and Deadlines
Blog April 2, 2020
Supreme Court Rules States "Arrrrgh" Immune from Copyright Infringement Suits
Blog March 27, 2020