Article

USPTO Returns Merits-Based IPR and PGR Institution Decisions to PTAB

 Fish & Richardson

Authors

Need to know 

Effective November 16, 2026, the PTAB again assumed responsibility for deciding, on Director Squires’ behalf, whether to institute referred IPR and PGR trials based on the merits. The Director, however, maintains control of discretionary and other non-merits considerations and overall institution policy. 


On November 10, 2026, U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) Director John A. Squires and General Counsel and Supervisory Solicitor John F. Duffy issued a memorandum announcing that the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) will determine, on the Director’s behalf, whether to institute inter partes review (IPR) and post-grant review (PGR) proceedings based on merits-based considerations. The change is effective November 16, 2026, and applies to any IPR or PGR not then subject to a notice referring the case for consideration of the merits. 

Under the updated process, the Director continues to review non-merits-based considerations, including discretionary considerations, and to set the USPTO’s overarching institution policy. The Office explained that this approach will allow the Director to apply discretionary considerations consistently while drawing on the PTAB judges’ technical expertise and experience in analyzing the merits of patentability challenges. 

Background 

The Office explained that its decision to return merits-based considerations to the PTAB reflects several developments over the past year: 

  • PTAB judges assisted and advised on more than 325 decisions involving merits-based considerations. 
  • The Office’s Learning from Outcomes to Optimize Patents (LOOP) training program connected lessons from America Invents Act (AIA) trial proceedings to the examining corps to improve patent quality. 
  • The Office’s PTAB Support, Training, Resources, Opportunities, Networking, and Guidance (STRONG) program included sessions on patent law at the time of the AIA and the “reasonable likelihood” standard for instituting IPRs. 

Merits guidelines  

Panels must apply five guidelines, which the memorandum describes as illustrative rather than exhaustive: 

  1. For any prior-art ground, the petition must explain element by element how the art discloses or renders obvious every limitation of every challenged claim. Merely pointing to an examiner’s findings does not satisfy 37 C.F.R. §§ 42.104(b)(4) and 42.204(b)(4).  
  2. The PTAB will deny institution if the petitioner fails to make the required showing for a substantial majority of the challenged claims.  
  3. The PTAB will deny institution if the patent owner’s preliminary response raises a reasonable argument, well-supported by reliable and credible evidence, that the petitioner fails the institution standard for a substantial majority of the challenged claims. 
  4. The PTAB will also deny institution if it independently determines that such an argument shows the petitioner fails the institution standard for a substantial majority of the challenged claims.  
  5. Under guidelines (2) through (4), if the arguments for and against unpatentability of a particular claim are both reasonably supported (i.e., in equipoise), that claim does not count as meeting the IPR “reasonable likelihood” standard or the PGR “more likely than not” standard. 

The memorandum also identifies a prior adjudication upholding claims of the challenged patent or a related patent as another scenario that may indicate the petitioner has not met its burden. 

Reinterpretation of “reasonable likelihood” standard 

The memo appears to raise the bar for institution by analogizing the institution standard for IPR to that for preliminary injunctions. Courts apply the "reasonable likelihood" standard to adjudicate preliminary injunctions, which the Federal Circuit has held requires the movant to show that it "will likely prove" its case. If the party opposing the injunction raises a "substantial question" concerning validity, enforceability, or infringement, the injunction should not issue. The memo states that this is the "context for the minimum institution thresholds," suggesting that petitioners may now be required to show that they "will likely prove" their case to satisfy the "reasonable likelihood" standard.  

Takeaways 

  • The Director remains the gatekeeper on discretionary issues. Arguments about discretionary denial will continue to be addressed at the Director level, so petitioners and patent owners should continue tailoring those arguments to the Director’s evolving policy. 
  • PTAB judges will again decide the merits of institution. Petitions and preliminary responses should be written with the PTAB’s technical expertise and the “reasonable likelihood” standard in mind. 
  • “Reasonable likelihood” may be applied with increased scrutiny. Petitioners will need to scrutinize whether the strength of their prior art challenges is likely to demonstrate a likelihood of prevailing. Patent owners, meanwhile, may be incentivized to present strong, evidence-supported arguments in the preliminary response that raise a reasonable question as to whether the petition has shown that it will likely prove its case if instituted.