Search Team

Search by Last Name
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
L
M
N
O
P
Q
R
S
T
U
V
W
X
Y
Z

IP LitigationFederal Circuit

Manufacturer claims should proceed first and should have been severed and transferred to more convenient venue

June 27, 2014

IP LitigationFederal Circuit

Manufacturer claims should proceed first and should have been severed and transferred to more convenient venue

June 27, 2014

Back to Fish's Litigation Blog

 

Federal Circuit grants mandamus, orders severance of a claim against Nintendo from claims against its retailers, and orders transfer of the Nintendo claim and a stay of the retailer claims.  Where infringement allegations are brought against a manufacturer and its customer (e.g., retailer), the manufacturer is the “true defendant,” and its suit “generally take[s] precedence.”  Slip op. at 4.

In re Nintendo of America, Inc., ___ F.3d ___ (Fed. Cir. June 25, 2014) (NEWMAN, Rader, Hughes) (E.D. Tex: Gilstrap) (3 of 5 stars) 

Not only did convenience and fairness outweigh the plaintiff’s choice of forum, but the plaintiff’s desire to pursue the highest royalty rate among defendants is similarly outweighed by the fact that the claim against the retailers requires resolution of the claims against Nintendo.  “Since Nintendo’s liability is predicate to recovery from any of the defendants, the case against Nintendo must proceed first.”  Id. at 6.  Transfer and severance were appropriate because “all of Nintendo’s identified witnesses reside in the transferee forum or would find travel to and from that venue significantly more convenient” and “no witness was identified as residing in the Eastern District of Texas.”  Id. at 5.

Related Tags

appellate
CAFC Summary
Federal Circuit

Blog Authors

Headshot
Joanna M. Fuller | Associate

Ms. Fuller represents pharmaceutical and high tech clients in patent litigation nationwide. Her cases have encompassed a wide range of technology, including pharmaceuticals, video coding, backup and recovery software, GPS technology, medical software, network security software,...

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *